Is Tutoring Working? 6 Signs to Look for Beyond Grades
Updated: Nov 2
You’re investing time, money, and trust in your child’s education. You deserve a clear picture of what’s improving and where they still need support. After years of tutoring, I understand why parents so often ask me, “How do I know tutoring is working?”
As a chemistry tutor, I want your child to leave with a clearer understanding and the confidence to use what we practiced. A finished worksheet tells me less than watching a student figure out how to begin the next problem. The goal is for their understanding to hold up when they work on their own.
You see what happens after the session ends. How your child talks about schoolwork, asks for help, and responds to a mistake gives us information a grade alone won’t provide. Here are six signs I encourage parents to look for.
1. They ask more specific questions
“I understand the first step, but I get lost here” gives us somewhere to begin. At home, notice whether your child identifies a confusing step or saves a question for tutoring. Recognizing where they need help is progress, even before they have the answer.
2. Their confidence comes with understanding
I love hearing a student feel better about chemistry. I also look for a reason behind the confidence: explaining an answer, noticing a mistake, or working with less hesitation. Ask the tutor for an example of something your child now understands better.
3. They have a way to get started
Opening their notes, choosing a first problem, or trying an example before asking for help are useful changes to notice. Compare your child with their own starting point. Beginning part of an assignment independently matters if they previously waited for help with every step.
4. They try again after a mistake
Progress includes what happens after the frustration. Does your child retrace a step, check an example, or return after a break? I want students involved in finding the mistake. At home, acknowledge the effort you see: “You went back and figured out where you got stuck.”
5. They trust the people helping them
I want students to feel comfortable saying, “Can you explain this another way?” Ask your child what happens when they’re confused during a session. They should feel heard and comfortable asking questions. If they feel rushed or embarrassed, bring the concern to the tutor.
6. They use a skill outside tutoring
After working through a chemistry problem together, I want to see whether a student uses the approach on a new example. At home, notice whether familiar work needs less help. Ask the tutor, “Which parts are they doing on their own now?”
How to help at home
Start with one question for your child: “What’s feeling easier, and what are you still getting stuck on?” Listen before offering a solution.
Then ask the tutor how to support the work between sessions. You don’t need to relearn the subject. Your role might be helping your child make time for a short practice task, keeping their notes available, or encouraging them to bring an unfinished problem to the next session.
A message to send your tutor
“Hi! I wanted to check in and see how sessions are going. What’s going well for [child’s name], and where is she still getting stuck? What are you working on next? Is there anything I should be doing at home to help between sessions?”
Agree on one next step and when to check back. For example, the tutor might recommend a few practice problems and ask your child to mark where they get stuck. Include your child in the plan so they know what’s expected.
What if grades haven’t improved?
Ask the tutor to review recent work with you. A course average might still include earlier tests or missing assignments. Find out which skills are improving and which errors keep appearing.
If progress is unclear, ask what the tutor will change and when you’ll review the result. Confidence matters, and you should also expect a clear explanation of what your child is learning.
At Tremont Tutors, I want parents to feel comfortable asking these questions. Your observations help us understand how learning is going beyond the session and what support your child needs next.
About the author
Madeline (Maddie) Montz is the founder of Tremont Tutors and a chemistry tutor. She holds a master’s degree from Harvard Graduate School of Education and a B.S. in Chemistry from Providence College.


Comments